Restitution is not merely about returning an object to the place from which it was taken. It also involves examining the circumstances of its removal and the narratives that have accompanied its movement. Behind every restitution claim, therefore, lie issues of memory, justice, and sovereignty, as well as a fundamental question: from whose perspective is history told?
The year 2026 will mark a milestone in the history of cultural property restitution in France. The adoption of a new legislative framework represents a major step forward in the evolution of heritage law and now places restitution at the heart of cultural policies. It reflects a profound shift in perspective regarding collections, their history, and their circulation.
The issue of restitution has been a hot topic in political and cultural circles for decades. The 26 works from the Abomey Treasure returned to Benin, as well as El Hadj Omar Tall’s saber returned to Senegal, marked a political turning point and fulfilled President Macron’s promise made in Ouagadougou in 2017. These restitutions have gradually placed African cultural heritage at the center of a major diplomatic and cultural issue.
In 2026, the adoption of a law establishing a general framework for reviewing requests for the restitution of illicitly acquired cultural property marked a new historic milestone. It paves the way for a lasting evolution in heritage practices and law.
ARTS Program: Bringing Together Different Perspectives to Advance the Debate
For the past two years, the FMSH has sought to shed interdisciplinary light on these issues, which touch on memory, identity, cultural sovereignty, justice, and diplomacy. It is also interested in how the various stakeholders engage in dialogue and compare their perspectives.
The call for projects launched in 2025, “ARTS—Worlds in Action, Worlds in Reflection,” as well as the series of events “#Restitutions: Another Definition of the World,” developed in partnership with journalist Valérie Nivelon, are part of this initiative. By bringing together the perspectives of researchers, artists and cultural actors, diplomats, and politicians, the Foundation aims to foster dialogue and identify jointly developed, respectful, and sustainable courses of action.
Who Tells the Story?
“The history of Africa cannot be written solely by European specialists on Africa,” declared Emmanuel Macron on November 28, 2017. This raises an immediate question: who tells the story, and from whose perspective?
This question invites us to take a different look at the world, both past and present. It leads us to reexamine knowledge, legacies, and memories; to give voice to other perspectives; and to bring greater transparency to the history of the collections. For the objects in question are not merely works of art: they may carry ritual, social, political, or religious significance. Understanding their history and the circumstances of their acquisition requires meticulous research into their provenance.
This reflection on the past leads us to consider the future. Restitutions are not merely about returning objects to their territory of origin; they involve rebuilding the bonds between communities, institutions, and states. This is why the Sarr-Savoy report emphasizes that “heritage objects can thus redefine and redraw territorial boundaries.” To engage with restitution is therefore to examine a transformation of the world that is at once historical, cultural, geopolitical, and symbolic.
The universal that we must invent together must be built upon the world’s diversity
As the philosopher Souleymane Bachir Diagne points out, restitution is not merely the return of objects but an act of humanism rooted in relationship, reciprocity, and a shared future.
Alexandra Duperray, Assistant Director of the Research & International Affairs Division, Head of the ARTS Program
Article published in the fourth issue of the FMSH Journal.