The Impact of Government on Daily Life in Societies

Crossed Perspectives
Façade à colonnes
© Endless Exploration / Adobe Stock

From respecting international law to strategies of war targeting civilian populations, how do states’ decisions transform the lives of societies?

As residents of the Maison Suger in 2025–2026, legal scholar Carla Huerta and historian Sheldon Garon examine, each from their own field of research, the forms and limits of state power. One studies the role of law in regulating power and protecting rights; the other analyzes how states have made civilian populations targets of war, while simultaneously seeking to protect and mobilize them. Two complementary perspectives on the relationships between power, collective rules, and social realities.

***

A senior researcher at the Institute for Legal Research at the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM), Carla Huerta focuses on legal logic, the rule of law, and the connections between law and culture. As a fellow at Maison Suger, she is conducting a comparative study on constitutional culture in France and Mexico. Her research examines how constitutions—beyond their status as fundamental texts—are embedded in social consciousness and everyday practices, as well as the legal mechanisms that govern their revision.

Carla Huerta
© Carla Huerta

Why is international law no longer respected in conflicts today?

International law prohibits one state from invading or interfering in the affairs of another. Yet these rules are regularly ignored. The main reason: there is no authority capable of enforcing them by force. The UN Security Council can issue condemnations, but the major powers block decisions through their veto power. Impunity takes hold.

Added to this is the resurgence of the logic of power: some states consider their national interests to take precedence over common rules. The sovereignty of weaker nations becomes, in practice, negotiable. Governments at fault never openly admit this; they invoke “self-defense” or the “war on terror” to justify actions that clearly violate the law. Finally, the major international institutions established after 1945 are facing a crisis of legitimacy. When the most powerful states exempt themselves from the rules they helped create, international law is weakened.

How do constitutions take root in the social consciousness?

A constitution is a country’s fundamental law. It establishes citizens’ rights, the powers of the state, and the principles that guide communal life. Its primary function is to check the exercise of power and protect our rights. But how does it evolve from an official document into something living, rooted in society? First and foremost, this requires understanding it. A constitutional culture does not develop on its own: it requires that citizens understand what their Constitution guarantees, as well as its limitations and what it does not cover. This is built through education, starting in school, but also through major public debates, court decisions covered in the media, and moments of civic mobilization when threatened rights are collectively defended.

How does this translate into practice and everyday life?

In everyday life, citizens internalize the Constitution through two fundamental actions: exercising their own rights and respecting those of others. This dual process is at the heart of any vibrant constitutional culture. But this internalization goes further: it also involves recognizing that others have the same rights, even those with whom we disagree. The Constitution is not a tool for personal use; it is a shared framework.

In short: the Constitution protects each and every one of us from arbitrary power. But for it to fulfill this role, we must know it, understand its scope, and bring it to life in our daily lives—by invoking it for ourselves and respecting it for others. Constitutions are not merely legal documents. Over time, they shape the way a society understands what is just—and what it is willing to defend.

Carla Huerta, National Autonomous University of Mexico, in residence at Maison Suger from August 2025 to February 2026

 

***

How did it become “normal” for nations to seek to win wars not simply by destroying armies, but also by deliberately attacking cities and civilians.

At Sciences Po, historian Sheldon Garon leads the research project “The Global War Against Civilians, 1905–1945,” funded by an Advanced Grant from the European Research Council.

Through a study of several countries and both world wars, this project examines the growing role of civilian populations in military strategies: how did states come to target civilians to weaken the enemy, and how did they seek to protect and mobilize their own populations?

Sheldon Garon

How did civilian populations become full-fledged targets of warfare strategies in the 20th century?

My seven team members and I conduct research on Japan, China, Germany, Britain, Italy, France, the Soviet Union, United States, Spanish Civil War, and international law.

In view of the several conflicts today, we ask an uncomfortable question. How did it become “normal” for nations to seek to win wars not simply by destroying armies, but also by deliberately attacking cities and civilians. We also explore how this war on civilians shaped creation of “home fronts” that mobilized and protected civilians. The focus is on the First World War, interwar era, and Second World War. It was during those eras that it became an acceptable part of warfare—around the world—to bomb densely populated urban areas, blockade the enemy’s food supply, and attempt to “demoralize” the civilian population. The “fascist” nations were hardly the only ones to pursue these strategies. By the Second World War, the two greatest destroyers of cities were two of the greatest democracies: Britain and the United States. Moreover, it was the United States that mounted a massive food blockade against Japan called Operation STARVATION. Even after the Second World War, it was a normal part of strategy to target the civilian population in the Korean War and Vietnam War. Sadly, this has also be true in the wars of the 2020s.

How did nations seek to undermine the morale of enemy populations while maintaining the morale of their own people?

The key to these strategies was the new concept of civilian “morale,” which emerged during the First World War.  Morale became defined as the collective mood of an entire nation. The bombers and blockaders assumed that they could target morale and that they could “break” it. The terrorized or starving population was then expected to force their government to surrender to the enemy. At the same time, states attempted to boost morale on the home front by regularly surveying the collective mood, guaranteeing food supplies, building air-raid shelters, and promoting patriotism. The Second World War became a grand struggle of “morale” between nations.

To what extent have these strategies succeeded in undermining civilian morale and influencing the outcome of wars?

The Allies heavily bombed German cities, but they failed to break German morale for several reasons. The Nazis had tight control over citizens; they adequately fed their people in part because they plundered food from the rest of Europe; and they rebuilt bombed cities with forced labor. In Japan on the other hand, the Americans significantly demoralized the civilian populace by destroying 66 cities, malnourishing civilians, and forcing more than 8 million Japanese to flee the cities. Bombing also had a severe impact on popular morale in Italy in 1943.

Our project revises common understandings that bombing conversely strengthens morale. In some important cases, nations surrendered when leaders recognized that their civilian populations had become too panicked and hungry to continue to support the war effort on the home front.

Sheldon Garon, Princeton University, in residence at Maison Suger from September 2025 to August 2026


Article published in the fourth issue of the FMSH Journal.

Events
La guerre mondiale
Seminar

The Global War on Civilians, 1905-1945: An ERC Project

29 January | Sheldon Garon Seminar
Jeudis de Suger-Carla Huerta
Seminar

The Concept of Constitution and the Control of the Constitutional Amendment Process

22 January | Carla Huerta Seminar
Published at 18 November 2026